April 22, 2024
When is it Time to Replace a Toilet?

There are many warning signs when it comes to replacing an appliance or fixture in your home. They may start underperforming. They may start making noise or emitting strange smells. For all of the appliances in your home, there are always at least some telltale signs that it is time to replace them.

For instance, if your toaster is burning or undercooking your toast even though you have not changed the setting, this may be a sign that the timing device or sensors are going bad. And because toasters are cheap to replace, it makes more sense to just buy a new one and not worry about paying for a costly repair.


Toilets are not cheap like toasters. They should always be repaired when at all possible. A new toilet can cost anywhere from a few hundred to several thousands of dollars. Repair is the ideal situation.

But when there are problems with your toilet that are too severe to repair then you have to “bite the bullet” so to speak. Below you can find a list of problems you will face with your toilet that may require you buying a new one altogether:

Cracks and Major Damage

If the porcelain is cracked then you can pretty much count on the fact that the crack will grow and grow and eventually be catastrophic. A cracked toilet can hold itself together for a while but there may be major leakage happening underneath the toilet. It could be doing major damage to your home.

Constant Issues

If your toilet is always running or you find yourself needing to replace or repair it too often, it may be time to just buy a brand new one. A new toilet will be under warranty and you can bet that if any problems arise after installing it, then you have recourse. You can make a claim against the company and they will fix or repair any issues you have.


If your toilet is old and outdated it may be time to think of getting a nice upgrade. New toilets look sleeker and they can really add to a modern look in your home. Jake, a plumber in Melbourne Florida writes “A new toilet and a bathroom remodel can add many more thousands of dollars to your home value should you decide to sell it.”

Save Money in the Long Run

A new toilet will only use 1.6 gallons per flush whereas an older one may use more than double that. It doesn’t seem like much on a flush by flush basis but over a period of ten years these water savings will basically pay for the cost of the toilet. Plus, you will be saving money from not having any leaks. A new toilet was designed with efficiency in mind as the planet starts trying to be less wasteful.


A new toilet can improve your water bill, improve the look and feel of your bathroom and help alleviate costly and annoying repairs. If you have been thinking about replacing your toilet, chances are you probably should.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *